Pennsylvania's Trusted Trailer Dealer Since 2014
Four dealerships. Thousands of trailers sold. One straightforward way of doing business — honest pricing, real inventory on the ground, and a team that actually answers the phone.
Shop Our Inventory Find Your Nearest LocationTrailers Are All We Do — And We Do Them Right
Best Choice Trailers started with a simple idea: trailer buying shouldn't be complicated, and it shouldn't feel like a negotiation tactic every time you walk on a lot. We built our business around straightforward pricing, real inventory you can actually see and touch, and a staff that knows the difference between a 5,200 lb axle and a 7,000 lb axle without having to look it up.
What started as a single lot in Carlisle has grown into four dealerships across Pennsylvania — Carlisle, Irwin, Evans City, and West Middlesex — each stocked with utility, dump, equipment, car hauler, enclosed, gooseneck, deckover, and specialty trailers from the industry's top manufacturers.
Unlike dealers who sell trailers "on the side" of another business, trailers are our entire focus. That means our staff isn't guessing — they're trained on GVWRs, axle configurations, coupler types, and towing capacities every single day.
Talk to Our Team
Why Pennsylvania Buyers Choose Best Choice Trailers
We've sold thousands of trailers to owner-operators, contractors, farmers, and weekend haulers across the Northeast. Here's what keeps them coming back.
Unbeatable Selection
With roughly 1,000 trailers in stock across our four lots, we carry one of the largest selections in the Northeast — utility, dump, equipment, enclosed cargo, car hauler, deckover, gooseneck, livestock, and more.
One-Call Shopping
Many of our customers travel a distance to buy from us, so we focus on answering your questions correctly the first time — before you ever make the trip.
Simple, Honest Pricing
The price you see is the price you pay. No inflated "sale" pricing games, no back-and-forth over what was quoted. Our everyday price is often better than competitors' "sale" price anyway.
Post-Sale Support
Before you leave our lot, we make sure you're properly equipped to tow — ball mounts, wiring, brake controllers, and more. We go beyond just hitching up.
Warranty Service, In-House
We service what we sell. We stock the "wearable" parts most trailers need and handle warranty work quickly, often with little notice.
Delivery Available
Can't make it to the lot? We offer delivery to most areas — often for less than you'd expect.
Sound Advice, Not Just a Sales Pitch
We've sold thousands of trailers, and we routinely hear the same thing from customers: "thanks for taking the time to explain the differences." Our job is to help you pick out — or spec out — a trailer that actually fits what you're hauling, not just move inventory off the lot.
That includes accepting trade-ins of any size or condition, offering custom builds when we don't have exactly what you need in stock, and giving you a fair value whether you're buying, trading, or just cashing out.
Financing Available on Nearly Every Trailer
Approval is typically quick — often around 15 minutes — with straightforward terms and competitive rates. All you need is a valid ID to get started.
See Financing OptionsProudly Serving the Northeast & Mid-Atlantic
Buyers travel to our four Pennsylvania locations from across the region, including Pennsylvania, New York, Ohio, New Jersey, Maryland, Delaware, West Virginia, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, Connecticut, Maine, and Virginia.
What Our Customers Say
Real reviews from real buyers across our four locations.
"I bought a 20-foot Sur-Trac deckover and am happy with it. I wanted a trailer that was built well but lightweight, and Best Choice had it. Pleased with the service overall."
"Put a deposit on an all-aluminum Nordtek trailer and a few weeks later paid in full and picked it up. The experience was straightforward and stress-free. Nothing but good things to say."
"I've purchased 3 trailers from Best Choice Trailers since June of 2025, and every transaction has been absolutely great with top-notch customer service. Amazing staff all around!"
"Great inventory, great customer service, smooth transaction. Couldn't recommend this place more."
"Mark and James excel in customer service! In addition to offering a high-quality product, they genuinely prioritize making a difference — it truly sets them apart."
"We bought and have our trailer serviced here. They always treat us right."
Ready to Find the Right Trailer?
Browse our live inventory or call your nearest location — our team will help you find exactly what fits your job.
Browse Inventory Call (717) 220-4220Four Pennsylvania Locations to Serve You
Stop by, call ahead, or get directions — every lot is stocked and staffed with trailer specialists ready to help.
Carlisle, PA
Irwin, PA
Evans City, PA
West Middlesex, PA
Common Questions About Best Choice Trailers
How long has Best Choice Trailers been in business?
Best Choice Trailers has been serving Pennsylvania and the surrounding region since 2014, growing from a single Carlisle location to four dealerships across the state.
Do you offer financing?
Yes. We offer financing on nearly every trailer we sell. Approval is typically fast — often around 15 minutes — with straightforward terms. Visit our Financing page for current rates and requirements.
Do you service trailers you didn't sell?
Our service bays are focused on the brands we carry, but give your local location a call with your trailer's make and issue — we're happy to let you know what we can do.
Do you accept trade-ins?
Yes, we take trade-ins of any size or condition and will give you a fair, ballpark value, often from just a description and a few photos. A valid title is required.
Can you deliver a trailer to me?
In most cases, yes. We offer delivery to most areas directly, or can arrange a hauler, often for less than customers expect.
Can you build me a custom trailer?
If we don't have exactly what you need on the lot, we can often source or build it. Build times are typically faster than people expect, and custom units often cost about the same as one already on the lot.
Stop By, Call, or Browse Online — We're Ready to Help
Whichever Best Choice Trailers location is closest to you, our team is ready to help you find the right trailer for the job.
View All Inventory Contact Us